Sending the wrong message by Subhradip Karmakar
11 January, 2022 | Jaya Choudhary
According to the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME), Washington, omicron infections are set to surge in the next two to three months and may infect1-2 billion people globally.
Omicron ( B1.1.529) quickly evolved to become a VoC within a few months’ time, spreading from S Africa to several nations worldwide. The Technical Advisory Group on SARS-CoV-2 Virus Evolution (TAG-VE) monitoring the evolution of SARS-CoV-2 was convened to assess this variant after it was first reported to WHO from South Africa on 24 November 2021 from a specimen collected on 9 November 2021. The detection of B1.1.529 quickly coincided with a surge in COVID19 cases establishing it as the dominant variant. By the time travel advisories and other restrictions could kick in, Omicron already spread to 89 countries (as of 18th Dec 2021) infecting millions. According to the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation (IHME), Washington, omicron infections are set to surge inthe next two to three months and may infect1-2 billion people globally. What makes B1.1.529 special is the sheer number of mutationsit accumulated(32 vs 12) as compared to the delta(B1.617.2), plus the rapidness it is spreading with an estimated Ro of 2.69 (vs 1.69 for the delta variant). For a populous country like India with over 8 lakh active cases, and a positivity of ~10-15%, the stakes are higher. The healthcare system that is already stretched beyond its capacity has seen a further dent with several HCW exposed and quarantined.
Amidst the rising cases, the administration has to enforce lockdown, containment zones, and travel restrictions which may, in turn, affect the economy.However, it seems during this crisis, the public is getting influenced by a different set of narratives, derived from an overall short term observation, poor understanding of the full nature& scale of this variant, inadequate testing,surveillance, genome sequencing,as well asoverlookingthe long term health consequences of Omicron on adults as well as in children and pregnant women. This lack of our knowledge is giving rise to numerous misleading statements even by the professionals, labeling Omicron to be a mild,benign variant, a variant of least concern, a variant that needs nearly no hospitalization or is associated with very low mortality. Taken to the public domain, this may create callousness and a sense of anarchy in following COVID-appropriate behavior like social distancing, double masking, or getting tested and vaccinated. This also falsely justifieshosting super-spreader events like religious and political rallies, ignoring the law and order, and downsizing the potential risk. We need to accept from all our past experiences that our understanding of the overall COVID pandemic is still very naïve and almost nil for this newvariant. Still, a vast majority of the PCR/NAAT-based detection is not targeted to B1.1.529. SGTF(S Gene Target failure) is rarely used in diagnostic labs. With India’s sequencing agency,The Indian SARS-CoV-2 Genomics Consortium(INSACOG), sequencing a minuscule 2-3% of all positive cases, we are still in an ocean of uncertainties to comment on the real number of genuine Omicron cases.
Going by the average consensus worldwide, even if 60-80% is Omicron, that still implies that Delta and other variants are out there and may retaliate any time. Moreover we don’t know if B1.1.529 is just a transient quasi-species on its evolutionary trajectory in the process of evolving to a more virulent form. We also don’t know if Omicron will make us permissive for co-infection by another variants that are perhaps mutating at some corner of the world. The rapid spread of B1.1.529 with its extremely high transmissibility could in theory wipe out COVID-specific memory B/T cells, that many of us might be banking on, making them ineffective and futile. Worst, if it blunts the effect of the COVID-19 vaccine, acting as a “decoy virus” exhausting the pool of effector immune cells before another lethal variant steps in. With all these possibilities, labeling omicron as a harmless variant and taking the guard off is the last thing one should ever do. Further, the decision for a booster dose needs some serious thoughts following the philosophy that “more is not always the best”. Serology testing has shown a lesser efficiency in vaccine-induced neutralization against the new variant (though surely it avoids a severe disease outcome).Under these conditions, there is no credible evidence to show that a 3rd jab will make things all right.
We need to consider that sometimes a higher dose of antibodies produced may in fact facilitate virus infection by the process of ADE(antibody-dependent enhancement). Though well observed in Dengue virus infection and not yet in SARS-CoV2, the probability how-so-ever small still remains. We have already seen a massive breakthrough re-infection amongst those fully vaccinated making it apparent that the vaccines are not capable enough to prevent new infection or virus transmission. Whether adding a booster dose to ramp the antibody level will do any benefit is highly uncertain and should be only considered based on solid science and rigorous clinical trials, rather than speculation. Also drawing parallels between Ab titers with disease protection can not only be misleading but also erroneous. For a country as large and populous as India with just 64% fully vaccinated with a double dose (as of December 30th, 2021),demand for a 3rd booster dose is highly ambitious. Making the right choices and sending the right messages, more so in pandemic times might hold the key to overcoming the ongoing crisis. Sending the wrong message may do more harm than the virus itself.
- Classification of Omicron (B.1.1.529): SARS-CoV-2 Variant of Concern. URL : https://www.who.int/news/item/26-11-2021-classification-of-omicron-(b.1.1.529)-sars-cov-2-variant-of-concern( last assessed 11th Jan 2022)
- India COVID cases . URL : https://www.mohfw.gov.in/
- It’s dangerous to take Omicron lightly. URL : https://indianexpress.com/article/opinion/columns/its-dangerous-to-take-omicron-lightly-7710469/
- Lack of genome sequencing capacity hampers India’s efforts to track the spread of Omicron: URL : https://scroll.in/article/1013438/lack-of-genome-sequencing-capacity-hampers-indias-efforts-to-track-the-spread-of-omicron (( last assessed 11th Jan 2022)
- Narayan R, Tripathi S. Intrinsic ADE: The Dark Side of Antibody Dependent Enhancement During Dengue Infection. Front Cell Infect Microbiol. 2020 Oct 2;10:580096. doi: 10.3389/fcimb.2020.580096. PMID: 33123500; PMCID: PMC7573563.
- Lisboa Bastos M, Tavaziva G, Abidi SK, Campbell JR, Haraoui LP, Johnston JC, Lan Z, Law S, MacLean E, Trajman A, Menzies D, Benedetti A, Ahmad Khan F. Diagnostic accuracy of serological tests for covid-19: systematic review and meta-analysis. BMJ. 2020 Jul 1;370:m2516. doi: 10.1136/bmj.m2516. PMID: 32611558; PMCID: PMC7327913.
BY- Subhradip Karmakar, Additional Professor, All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi, India.