WWE SummerSlam 2025 vs WrestleMania 41: Which Reigns Supreme?

SummerSlam has long stood as WWE’s second-biggest annual spectacle, but history has shown it can sometimes outshine the flagship WrestleMania. With SummerSlam 2025’s full lineup now unveiled and WrestleMania 41 in the rearview, it’s time to put them head-to-head.

Star Power on Display in WrestleMania and SummerSlam

Both WrestleMania 41 and SummerSlam 2025 boast an incredible cast. Big names like John Cena, CM Punk, Cody Rhodes, Rhea Ripley, Gunther, Roman Reigns, Jey Uso, and Logan Paul make appearances across both cards. In terms of sheer star presence, neither show held back.

One notable absence is Seth Rollins. He’s currently holding the Money in the Bank briefcase, having sided with Paul Heyman at WrestleMania and teamed up with Bron Breakker and Bronson Reed. But his leg injury, supposedly suffered at Saturday Night’s Main Event, could keep him off the SummerSlam card.

Wrestling journalist Dave Meltzer insists Rollins isn’t genuinely injured, suggesting it’s a scripted angle. While Meltzer is respected, his track record has been patchy recently, so this news remains uncertain.

If Rollins is indeed healthy, there’s a strong chance he shows up in the CM Punk vs. Gunther World Heavyweight Championship main event on Night 1 of SummerSlam, possibly walking out with the title.

WrestleMania 41: Mixed Bag of Moments

When WrestleMania 41 aired over two nights, it brought a mix of action, surprises, and confusion. On Night 1, standout moments included Jey Uso beating Gunther for the World Heavyweight Championship, and Tiffany Stratton retaining the WWE Women’s title against Charlotte in a strong match.

The Triple Threat between Rollins, Reigns, and Punk closed the night with high drama and was arguably the highlight. Matches like Jade Cargill vs. Naomi and Jacob Fatu’s win over LA Knight gave the night a strong rhythm.

Night 2 had its moments but failed to build on Night 1’s momentum. Cena vs. Rhodes, while historic with Cena breaking Ric Flair’s title record, fell flat emotionally. Logan Paul beat AJ Styles, and Randy Orton took down Joe Hendry in just over three minutes, adding to the disjointed feel of the night.

The absence of The Rock, despite heavy fan speculation, didn’t help. Originally, plans had involved Rock in a key storyline twist, but they never came to pass. Cena’s involvement, seemingly in cahoots with The Rock, lacked payoff. The entire narrative felt undercooked.

Unreal Insights: What WrestleMania 41 Could Have Been

Thanks to WWE’s Netflix series Unreal, fans were given a peek into what WrestleMania 41 was originally meant to deliver. And honestly, it might’ve been better that way.

The early plans featured stacked multiman ladder matches for the U.S. and Intercontinental titles. Travis Scott was set to be in Rey Mysterio’s corner, and Becky Lynch was supposed to team with Charlotte against Iyo Sky and Asuka. CM Punk was to challenge Gunther at WrestleMania, not SummerSlam.

There was even a teased Roman Reigns vs. Seth Rollins match and a Bad Bunny vs. Dominik Mysterio showdown. None of those played out, leaving fans wondering what went wrong.

Cena’s heel turn also didn’t land the way WWE hoped. It lacked the emotional clarity needed for a swerve of that magnitude. Fans expected fireworks but got a slow burn that fizzled out.

Night 1 still gets credit for its energy. Heyman stole the show, and the women’s title matches delivered. But when only a few matches across two nights truly shine, that’s a problem for what’s meant to be wrestling’s grandest stage.

SummerSlam 2025: Two Main Events With Real Buzz

SummerSlam 2025 looks better balanced, on paper at least, largely due to two standout main events. CM Punk taking on Gunther has electricity behind it, especially with the cloud of mystery surrounding Seth Rollins’ status.

Punk hasn’t held gold since returning in late 2023, and he’s overdue. His big-stage presence, especially in a title chase, makes this match feel massive, more so than many of WrestleMania 41’s offerings.

Then there’s Cena vs. Rhodes II, which is far more promising this time around. With no Rock to overcomplicate things, the focus stays on the story. Plus, the Street Fight stipulation helps mask Cena’s slower pace while opening doors for brutal storytelling.

A potential double turn, Rhodes going heel and Cena turning face, could freshen things up for both stars. Cena has only a few appearances left, and letting him chase the Intercontinental Championship (the only title missing from his resume) would be the perfect swan song.

ALSO READ: England’s Chris Woakes Ruled Out Of 5th Test vs India Due To Shoulder Injury