he clash between Shawn Michaels and Hulk Hogan at WWE SummerSlam 2005 was billed as a dream match, Icon vs Legend. However, what unfolded remains one of the most controversial bouts in WWE history. While fans expected an epic encounter, the reality was far more chaotic, marked by behind the scenes tension and in-ring theatrics that turned the match into an infamous spectacle.
A One-Sided Promotion Effort
According to reports, Shawn Michaels was visibly frustrated leading up to the event. The root of the issue? Hulk Hogan reportedly refused to participate in promoting the match, leaving Michaels to carry the build-up alone. While Michaels threw his full energy into hyping the bout, Hogan remained absent yet still walked away with the win. At the time, Michaels was in the prime of his career, while Hogan was semi-retired. The outcome left many questioning the decision-making behind the scenes.
Oversell or Protest?
During the match itself, Michaels’ performance was unusually exaggerated. From cartoonish bumps to overly dramatic reactions, it became clear that he was sending a message a not so subtle protest over the politics at play. WWE Hall of Famer Jim Ross recently reflected on the bout on his Grilling JR podcast, saying, “Vince loved Shawn like a son… He was defiant, but extremely talented, and that gave him leverage.” Ross hinted that Michaels was influenced by backstage voices and emotionally reactive during this period.
Hogan’s Pattern of Controversy
This wasn’t an isolated incident. Hogan faced similar backlash a year later when he defeated a rising Randy Orton at the same event, despite being semi-retired and contributing little to the match promotion. Once again, fans and industry insiders called out Hogan for stepping over rising stars and refusing to elevate the next generation.
What was meant to be a passing of the torch instead became a moment remembered for ego, controversy, and a dramatic oversell that still sparks debate today.
Also Read: Finn Balor Sparks Buzz With Bold Post WWE Appearance And One Word Statement
Karan Singh Rathod is a dedicated sports journalist known for his sharp attention to detail and flair for storytelling. With over a year of experience in writing and editorial work, he blends thorough research with compelling narratives to deliver engaging sports content. A passionate follower of football and cricket, he starts his mornings with a newspaper to stay updated with sports, fashion, and current affairs. Outside of journalism, Karan enjoys traveling and discovering new destinations.
